A federal judge has paused a lawsuit by Hoopes Vineyard and two other wineries challenging Napa County’s land use rules, saying it can’t proceed while a related case is still active in state court.

A federal judge has paused a lawsuit by Hoopes Vineyard and two other wineries challenging Napa County’s land use rules, saying it can’t proceed while a related case is still active in state court.
On March 28, U.S. District Judge Charles R. Breyer issued an Order Granting Motion to Dismiss on Younger abstention grounds, which essentially stays the federal case while one of the plaintiffs (Hoopes Vineyard) litigates a case in Napa County Superior Court. While Napa County has claimed the case has been dismissed, this is not entirely accurate given that “when Younger abstention applies, it is appropriate to dismiss the action without prejudice because the court has not addressed the merits of the action.” Howard v. City of Milton, 63 Fed. Appx 978 (2003).
The court did not make any decision as to the constitutionality of the Napa County ordinances and does not preclude the case from being refiled at a later date.
Regardless, Hoopes, Summit Lake and Smith-Madrone will be appealing the ruling. “This is a decision on abstention; it is absolutely not a decision on the merits of the case,” explains Joseph Infante, the attorney representing the three wineries. “But, the decision to wait until after the Hoopes state court case is resolved, including any appeals, significantly delays the constitutional rights of the wineries to have their day in court on the constitutional claims that have been raised in federal court which will not be decided in the state court case because they are not a part of that case and Smith-Madrone and Summit Lake are certainly not parties to that case.” he adds.
“Our appeal may take six or so months,” Infante added, “but we believe in fighting for the wineries’ constitutional rights.”
BY ALDER YARROW | VINOGRAPHY | Napa County has been biting the hand that feeds it for a long time. But now it seems intent upon dismembering the body itself. Under increased industry scrutiny and in the face of ongoing legal challenges, the Napa County Board…
On March 30th, beginning at 2:00 p.m., Hoopes Vineyard will livestream from Hoopes Oasis to answer any and all of your questions about this case.
Tune in on www.instagram.com/hoopesvineyard/
DM any questions you may have.
Attending in person is welcome also: Hoopes Oasis, 6204 Washington Street, Yountville (94558); please RSVP to [email protected]
We are inviting Supervisor Anne Cottrell and welcome anyone from the County to attend as well.
By Joe Campbell | Wine Bulletin | In the heart of Napa Valley, a significant legal battle is underway as three family-owned wineries—Hoopes Vineyard, Summit Lake Vineyards & Winery, and Smith-Madrone Winery—take on Napa County in federal court. This confrontation echoes the spirit of defiance found…
Lindsay Hoopes began her law career as an assistant district attorney in San Francisco, but now she’s tackling winemaking in Napa by Marisa Churchill | Oct 30, 2024, 12:15pm PDT | SF Eater | Hoopes Vineyard, located in Napa Valley, is just one of those memorable stops. It’s tucked down…
In the heart of California Wine Country, rigid local rules are choking small businesses and stifling growth | C. JARRETT DIETERLE | Reason.com | In 1976, at the now-famous Judgment of Paris, California wines took top prize over the French wines in a cross-Atlantic tasting competition. The…
By Giovana Godoy | Napa Valley Register | September 21, 2024 | As a frequent visitor to Napa Valley, I follow developments with interest. As I’ve been watching from afar, I’ve been wondering if Napa County’s offices are haunted. As I’ve followed the saga of…
Published by Vinetur Napa Valley Wineries Take Legal Action Against County Over Regulatory Disputes In a significant development for Napa Valley’s wine industry, three local wineries—Summit Lake Vineyards, Smith-Madrone Vineyards & Winery, and Hoopes Vineyard—filed a joint lawsuit in federal court last week, accusing Napa…
By Tim Fish | Wine Spectator | Sep 6, 2024 | Growing grievances against increasing local regulations on tasting room visits, construction and more come to a head Three Napa wineries filed a joint lawsuit against Napa County in federal court yesterday, alleging that county officials…